Our Roxie loves Kong toys but we have never tried the frisbee since she won’t catch it. But I would definitely say try the extreme kong frisbee since it isn’t made out of thin plastic. We buy the extreme kong toys and they last alot longer than any other brand by far. But I still wouldn’t just let him/her sit and chew on it because I figure it would break apart like the other kongs. But just from catching it I bet it would work great 🙂